| 2021 NJCAA DIVISION II WOMEN'S SOCCER FIRST TEAM ALL-AMERICANS | ||||||
| NAME | SCHOOL | POS | HT | YR | HOMETOWN | HIGH SCHOOL |
| Sammy Hecht | Muskegon CC | FWD | 5- 9 | FR+ | Holland, MI | Zeeland West |
| 2021 NJCAA DIVISION II WOMEN'S SOCCER HONORABLE MENTION ALL-AMERICANS | ||||||
| NAME | SCHOOL | POS | HT | YR | HOMETOWN | HIGH SCHOOL |
| Kendall Jones | Muskegon CC | FWD | 5- 8 | FR+ | Twin Lake, MI | Reeths-Puffer |
| Alison Bishop | Lake Michigan College | GK | 5- 8 | FR+ | Allegan, MI | Allegan |
| Cecielya Mernatti | Schoolcraft College | FWD | 5- 5 | FR | Roseville, MI | St. Clair Shores Lakeview |
| 2021 NJCAA DIVISION III WOMEN'S SOCCER ALL-AMERICANS | ||||||
| NAME | SCHOOL | POS | HT | YR | HOMETOWN | HIGH SCHOOL |
| Faith Webber | Delta College | FWD | 5- 8 | FR+ | Grand Blanc, MI | Grand Blanc |
| Maddy Boyes | Delta College | FWD | 5- 3 | SO+ | Freeland, MI | Freeland |
| Mackenzie Gilbert | Delta College | DEF | 5- 3 | FR+ | Davison, MI | Davison |
| 2021 NJCAA ALL-REGION XII WOMEN'S SOCCER TEAM | ||||||
| NAME | SCHOOL | POS | HT | YR | HOMETOWN | HIGH SCHOOL |
| Sammy Hecht | Muskegon CC | FWD | 5- 9 | FR+ | Holland, MI | Zeeland West |
| Alison Bishop | Lake Michigan College | GK | 5- 8 | FR+ | Allegan, MI | Allegan |
| Ceceilya Mernatti | Schoolcraft College | FWD | 5- 5 | FR | Roseville, MI | St. Clair Shores Lakeview |
| Taylor Meadows | Schoolcraft College | MID | 5- 4 | FR | Canton, MI | Dearborn Devine Child |
| Kendall Jones | Muskegon CC | MID | 5- 8 | FR+ | Twin Lake, MI | Reeths-Puffer |
| Anna Hosmer | Jackson College | FWD | 5- 8 | FR+ | Clarklake, MI | Columbia Central |
| Tania Villegas | Lake Michigan College | M/B | 4-11 | FR | Covert, MI | South Haven |
| Alexa Musk | Muskegon CC | DEF | 5- 5 | FR+ | Norton Shores, MI | Mona Shores |
| Holly Curtiss | Lake Michigan College | MID | 5- 1 | FR | Allegan, MI | Allegan |
| COACH OF THE YEAR: Jeff Lohman, Muskegon CC | ||||||
| 2021 FIRST TEAM ALL-MCCAA WOMEN'S SOCCER AWARDS | ||||||
| NAME | SCHOOL | POS | HT | YR | HOMETOWN | HIGH SCHOOL |
| Faith Webber | Delta College | FWD | 5- 8 | FR+ | Grand Blanc, MI | Grand Blanc |
| Sammy Hecht | Muskegon CC | FWD | 5- 9 | FR+ | Holland, MI | Zeeland West |
| Katie Bishop | Delta College | MID | 5- 7 | FR+ | Grand Blanc, MI | Homeschooled |
| Alison Bishop | Lake Michigan College | GK | 5- 8 | FR+ | Allegan, MI | Allegan, MI |
| Ceceilya Mernatti | Schoolcraft College | FWD | 5- 5 | FR | Roseville, MI | St. Clair Shores Lakeview |
| Kendall Jones | Muskegon CC | MID | 5- 8 | FR+ | Twin Lake, MI | Reethes-Puffer |
| Taylor Meadows | Schoolcraft College | MID | 5- 4 | FR | Canton, MI | Dearborn Devine Child |
| Maddy Boyes | Delta College | FWD | 5- 3 | SO+ | Freeland, MI | Freeland |
| Anna Hosmer | Jackson College | FWD | 5- 8 | FR+ | Clarklake, MI | Columbia Central |
| Tania Villegas | Lake Michigan College | M/B | 4-11 | FR | Covert, MI | South Haven |
| Alex Musk | Muskegon CC | DEF | 5- 5 | FR+ | Norton Shores, MI | Mona Shores |
| PLAYER OF THE YEAR: Faith Webber, Delta College | ||||||
| COACH OF THE YEAR: Damon Amey, Delta College | ||||||
| 2021 SECOND TEAM ALL-MCCAA WOMEN'S SOCCER AWARD | ||||||
| NAME | SCHOOL | POS | HT | YR | HOMETOWN | HIGH SCHOOL |
| Holly Curtiss | Lake Michigan College | MID | 5- 1 | FR | Allegan, MI | Allegan |
| Allison Beirgeder | Kellogg CC | FWD | 5- 3 | FR | Battle Creek, MI | Pennfield |
| Carley Bolen | Delta College | FWD | 5- 6 | FR+ | Tawas, MI | Tawas |
| Nora Brown | Muskegon CC | F/M | 5- 6 | SO+ | Norton Shores, MI | Mona Shores |
| Ella Moore | Jackson College | MID | 5- 2 | FR | Jackson, MI | Jackson |
| Livia Dangel | Schoolcraft College | DEF | 5- 6 | FR | Westland, MI | John Glenn |
| Katlyn Judd | St. Clair County CC | D/M/F | 5- 1 | FR+ | Imlay City, MI | Imlay City |
| Kali Jimenez | Delta College | DEF | 5-10 | FR | Hemlock, MI | Hemlock |
| 2021 HONORABLE MENTION ALL-MCCAA WOMEN'S SOCCER | ||||||
| NAME | SCHOOL | POS | HT | YR | HOMETOWN | HIGH SCHOOL |
| Hailey Sanders | Ancilla College | MID | 5- 6 | FR+ | Winamac, IN | Winamac |
| Lauren Morris | St. Clair County CC | F/M | 5- 5 | FR+ | Marine City, MI | Marine City |
| Chloe Leugers | Kellogg CC | MID | 5- 2 | FR | Marshall, MI | Marshall |
| Olivia McKellar | Jackson College | FWD | 5- 4 | FR+ | Sparta, MI | Sparta |
| Mackenzie Gilbert | Delta College | DEF | 5- 3 | FR+ | Davison, MI | Davison |
| Abigail Badke | Jackson College | FWD | 5- 7 | SO+ | St. Clair, MI | St. Clair |
| Mikayla Bryant | Lake Michigan College | B | 5-11 | FR | Otsego, MI | Otsego |
| Kenzie Hare | Schoolcraft College | DEF | 5- 5 | FR | Garden City, MI | Garden City |
| Neysa Lynn | Schoolcraft College | DEF | 5- 3 | FR+ | Novi, MI | Novi |
| Joselyn Williams | St. Clair County CC | C/M | 5- 8 | FR | Port Huron, MI | Port Huron |
| Leah Postema | Jackson College | MID | 5- 5 | FR | Jenison, MI | Jenison |
| Paige Timpe | Delta College | MID | 5- 5 | FR+ | Plainwell, MI | Plainwell |
| Mariah Krone | Lake Michigan Colllege | FWD | 5- 4 | FR | Keeler, MI | Dowagiac |
| Reece Danford | Ancilla College | DEF | 5- 3 | FR+ | Knox, IN | Oregon-Davis |
| Natalie Egnatuk | Kellogg CC | MID | 5- 5 | FR | Marshall, MI | Marshall |
| 2021 MCCAA WOMEN'S SOCCER ALL-FRESHMAN TEAM | ||||||
| NAME | SCHOOL | POS | HT | YR | HOMETOWN | HIGH SCHOOL |
| Ceceilya Mernatti | Schoolcraft College | FWD | 5- 5 | FR | Roseville, MI | St. Clair Shores Lakeview |
| Taylor Meadows | Schoolcraft College | MID | 5- 4 | FR | Canton, MI | Dearborn Devine Child |
| Tania Villegas | Lake Michigan College | M/B | 4-11 | FR | Covert, MI | South Haven |
| Holly Curtiss | Lake Michigan College | MID | 5- 1 | FR | Allegan, MI | Allegan |
| Allison Beirgeder | Kellogg CC | FWD | 5- 3 | FR | Battle Creek, MI | Pennfield |
| Ella Moore | Jackson College | MID | 5- 2 | FR | Jackson, MI | Jackson |
| FRESHMAN OF THE YEAR: Ceceilya Mernatti, Schoolcraft College | ||||||